Often I hear that readers of this blog use statistics from the
Benchmarking Report for board and volunteer presentations. To make presenting this information easier, I
have uploaded a presentation ready copy of the report. Feel free to use it. My only
request is that you provide attribution with any data from the report that you
present.
Showing posts with label 2014 Benchmarking Survey. Show all posts
Showing posts with label 2014 Benchmarking Survey. Show all posts
Get Your Copy of the 2014 Membership Marketing Benchmarking Report
It is my pleasure to announce the release of the 2014
Membership Marketing Benchmarking Report. With site registration, a free
download of the report is available using this link.
Please download your copy of the report now and let me know what you think.
A final and full printed report has also just been mailed to
all of those organizations who participated in this year’s research.
This marks the sixth year that Marketing General
Incorporated (MGI) has surveyed associations to better understand what is going
on in the membership market and what is working best to recruit members, engage
new members, renew existing members, and reinstate former members. It also
marks the highest level of association participation with 865 separate
associations sharing their data.
The 2014 Report includes new questions related to social
media usage, email frequency and open rates, and who pays membership dues
(individuals or companies).
I think you will also find trend information from ongoing
questions over the past six years very useful. This year results show that the
majority of associations (53%) are seeing their membership counts continue to increase. However, average renewal rates for both
individual and trade associations eroded this past year.
The most important aspect of this report is that it goes beyond
cataloging the practices of responding associations; the Benchmarking Report
also takes these practices and cross-tabulates them with the membership outcomes
that associations are experiencing. The comparison of practices and better new
member input, renewal rates and overall growth provides strong directional
information to help you select the tactics and strategies that might fit into
your marketing plans for the upcoming year.
I hope that you find the 2014
Report of help as you seek to maximize the membership results for your
organization.
The Evolution of Association Membership Models
In the coming months, I am presenting two sessions on the
transitions and opportunities that are taking place in the packaging of
association memberships, otherwise known as membership models.
What an increasing number of organizations are doing is
re-packaging their traditional membership offering to appeal to new market
segments and to adjust to new business realities. They are encouraging the
market to drive their membership product instead of their bylaws.
There is one change in particular to highlight. An increasing number of individually based associations
appear to be offering both individual and institutional membership instead of
the traditional clear delineation between an individual membership and company
or institutionally based structure.
In fact, since starting our Membership Marketing
Benchmarking research, the proportion of associations reporting that they offer
a combination or “hybrid” membership has gone from 17% to 28%. And as the chart below shows, this has been
accompanied by a drop in associations’ reporting that they only provide
individual membership from 54% to 44%.
When one looks at the outcomes of adopting this hybrid
membership model, one can also see the wisdom of considering of these
changes. In my consulting experience, it
is not unusual to see organizations that offer both individual and
institutional membership options achieving five to ten points’ better renewal rates
with their institutional membership offering compared to their individual
membership. Additionally, our 2014
Membership Marketing Benchmarking Report highlights the mean renewal rate for
individual membership associations is 76% and the mean for combination
associations is 80%. Both, however, fall
short of the mean renewal rate for trade or institutionally based associations
of 85%.
Perhaps the reason for these better renewal rates is an institutional
membership will typically be paid from a company budget, not out of an individual’s
wallet. Also, an institutional
membership obviously supplies benefits to multiple people adding to the
potential endorsers of continuing the membership relationship.
Finally, offering a combination of membership may help with
recruiting new members. Our research
shows that combination associations were more likely than both trade and
individual membership organizations to report an increase in new members over
the past year.
One of the 4 P's of marketing is "product", so
adjusting the membership product to meet the changing market conditions is an
important strategy for associations. One
of these adjustments to the membership model that seems to have been
beneficial, in particular for individually based associations, is offering the
option for the members’ companies or institutions to join and hold the
membership as an organization.
Membership Growth Helps Increase All Association Products and Services
The famous quote from John F. Kennedy, “a rising tide lifts
all boats,” certainly applies to membership.
In our soon to be released Membership Marketing Benchmarking
Report, we cross-tabulated organizations that reported an increase in
membership numbers to the outcomes that they were experiencing in other areas
of the association.
When we compare associations who saw a decrease or no change
in membership over the past year to associations reporting growth in membership,
we see associations with increasing membership reporting better performance in many categories.
Here are the associations reporting increases in a category -- like meeting attendance or volunteerism -- broken out by the percentage who had memberships that Increased/Unchanged/ Decreased).
·
Attendance at annual conference/trade show (55%
vs. 45% and 34% respectively)
·
Attendance at professional development meetings
(52% vs. 38% and 33%)
·
Attendance of webinars (70% vs. 45% and 54%)
·
Volunteerism (37% vs. 30% and 17%)
·
Number of members who acquire or maintain certification
(59% vs. 42% and 36%)
·
Purchase of non-dues products (45% vs. 24% and
25%)
·
Purchase of non-dues services (46% vs. 28% and
17%)
·
Number of visits to members-only section of website
(61% vs. 48% and 36%)
Fundamentally, for most associations, members are the
driving force behind attendance, volunteerism, and purchases. Members pay the association to be
customer. A growing and thriving member
base contributes revenue and time to all areas of an association.
Using Membership Marketing Partners to Help with Your Membership Challenges
One of the questions that I find most interesting in our
Membership Marketing Benchmarking research is, “What are your organization’s
top challenges in growing membership?”
The answers fall into two broad categories. The first are environmental challenges
outside the organization. These are
situations like the economy, competing organizations, market perceptions, and
industry consolidation. The second are
institutional challenges inside the organization. These are challenges like the ability to
communicate value, insufficient staff, identifying prospects, lack of marketing
expertise, and the lack of a plan or strategy.
The outside challenges often need long-term strategic
changes in the organization and can be more difficult to address. However, the inside challenges many times can
be addressed by adding outside partners with specialized expertise for a period
of time.
For example, an experienced research firm can help an
organization better understand its value proposition and select the marketing
messages that best communicate it to members and prospects. And when peak work times are present, staff
can be supplemented through marketing temporary firms or contractors.
When identifying prospective members is the challenge, a
list broker can help. List brokers have numerous
tools and contacts available to help find prospects for your marketing efforts
and since they receive a commission from the owners of the prospect lists they
find for you, their services are effectively free to you as the list buyer.
Finally, there are a number of marketing firms that
specialize in membership marketing including my company, Marketing General Incorporated,
which often will provide a free consultation to help you define your needs and
possible solutions.
If your organization’s membership growth is being held back
by issues that can be addressed and solved by adding expertise from partners in
the membership marketing community, why not reach out and ask for
assistance?
What can be Done to Increase Renewal Rates?
Only 30% of associations participating in the 2014
Membership Marketing Benchmarking Report said that they have increased renewal
rates over the past year. And 27% of associations report that their renewal
rates had declined. Individual
associations in particular saw average rates drop from 79% to 76%.
So with this discouraging news, what should associations do? How can an association move from flat or declining renewals to better renewals?
So with this discouraging news, what should associations do? How can an association move from flat or declining renewals to better renewals?
One solution is to learn from the behaviors of what the
associations are doing that have seen an increase in retention. And the great news about data is that we can
look at the reported activities of respondents to the research to see
correlations with groups that are seeing increased renewals. These correlations do not necessarily mean
that any single activity will automatically change outcomes. However, when you see certain actions
correspond with better renewals for some associations, it makes sense to investigate
how these options might be used in your association and develop and test the
solution and then implement what works.
From our research, here are four categories of actions an
association might take that correlate with increasing renewal rates.
1.
Increased
Member Usage – In many cases, when there was an increase reported in the
attendance or purchasing of an association’s products and services there was
also an increase in renewal rates over the baseline of 30%. For example, 41% of the associations that
reported an increase in attendance at professional development meetings saw an
increase in renewal rates. Similarly,
43% who reported an increase in book and directory purchases saw and increase
in renewals and 37% who reported an increase in annual conference attendance
saw an increase in renewals.
2.
Increased
Membership Marketing Budgets – In most cases, when there was an increase
reported in membership marketing budgets, there was also an increase in renewal
rates over the 30% baseline. For
example, 50% of the associations that reported an increase in spending on renewals
saw an increase in renewal rates.
Similarly, 44% who reported an increase in recruitment spending and 39%
who reported an increase in on-boarding and engagement spending saw an increase
in renewals.
3.
Increase
Payment Options – Providing additional ways for members to pay also can
help increase renewals. For example, 44%
of associations offering multi-year renewal options saw an increase in renewal
rates along with 43% of associations offering and early bird renewal discount,
and 41% of associations offering an automatic credit card renewal option. Again, these are against a 30% baseline of
associations reporting an increase in renewal rates.
4.
Increase Renewal
Activity – The tactical steps an organization takes to try to increase
renewal rates also has an impact on the outcomes. For example, 71% of associations that extend
a grace period two months or more to allow members to renew have renewal rates
over 80% compared to 50% of associations that limit the grace period. Also, 69% of associations that include phone
contacts as part of their renewal efforts have renewal rates over 80% compared
to 44% of associations who do not use phone efforts. And 66% of associations that use direct mail
as part of their renewal efforts have renewal rates over 80% compared to 45% of
associations who do not use direct mail.
These findings are just a highlight from the results of our
benchmarking research. A full, printed
report is scheduled to be distributed to survey participants in June. Association Membership Growth Surges
The theme for the 2014 Membership Marketing Benchmarking
Report is the continued positive growth in association total membership
numbers.
A total of 894 associations participated in the research
this year and altogether 53% of them reported growth in their overall membership
numbers. While 15% said that their
membership stayed the same, 28% saw a decline, and 4% were unsure if their
membership grew or declined. A full 24%
of associations saw total membership growth of 6% or higher. While only 8% of associations saw total
membership declines of 6% or more.
Interestingly, the growth again this year did not come from
increased renewal rates, but from higher levels of new member recruitment. Overall, 59% of all respondents said that
their new member input had grown. But of
those associations showing an increase
in total membership, 70% said that their new member input had increased. While only 17% of those associations showing
a decrease in total membership said
that their new member input had increased.
The same was not true with renewals. Only 30% of all respondents reported an increase
their renewal rate this year (down from 35% last year). In fact, the mean renewal rate reported this
year fell from 79% to 76% for individual membership associations and from 87%
to 85% for trade associations. It did
increase from 76% to 80% for hybrid associations (those that offer both
individual and organizational membership).
Still maintaining strong renewal rates obviously assists
with growth. Of those associations that
report an increase in overall membership, 56% of them had renewal rates of 80%
or better. Conversely, of those
associations that reported a decline in overall membership only 26% had renewal
rates of 80% or better.
This is the sixth consecutive year that this membership
marketing benchmarking research has been conducted. A full, printed report is scheduled to be
distributed to survey participants in June.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)




