Speaking Engagements

Showing posts with label Case Study. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Case Study. Show all posts

A Membership Growth Case Study

This article is an edited excerpt from the book Membership Recruitment: How to Grow Recurring Revenue, Reach New Markets, and Advance Your Mission. Find it on Amazon.


The American Nurses Association (ANA) is the premier professional association representing the interests of the nation’s registered nurses through joint membership with affiliated state nurses’ associations. In just over five years, ANA has grown membership by 61 percent, with annual growth rates ranging from 6 percent to 9 percent.[1]

However, for years, a growing membership was not the norm for ANA. In fact, by 2011, ANA membership had declined from well over 100,000 members to 90,000 members due to the disaffiliation of five of ANA’s state associations and inconsistent membership marketing efforts.

ANA leadership realized that significant changes were needed to reverse the membership decline and stop the hemorrhaging. The board, executive director, and membership vice president set a goal for ANA to become a high-growth membership organization. The two decisions to accomplish this change were to focus on improving the membership value proposition and allocating significant budget dollars for an ongoing membership recruitment effort.

Additionally, the membership team at ANA committed to function as a “learning organization” to identify innovations in membership marketing, aggressively test them, measure and analyze the results, and then deploy them in the recruitment efforts. To help accomplish these goals, ANA decided to partner with a direct response agency to add to their capabilities and expertise.

To improve the value proposition and bring better alignment between the price and membership benefits, ANA launched a program with their state nurses’ associations to offer a reduced-price standard membership category for new members. At the same time, existing members received additional benefits through a new category called Premier membership. Through these multi-level membership categories, ANA was able to present an economical membership option to potential new members without sacrificing revenue growth from the loyal current membership base.

Concurrently with enhancing membership value, ANA launched a membership recruitment program built around market testing and analysis. ANA’s testing efforts included:

·       Tests of creative to determine what messages, copy, and graphics are most effective;

·       Audience tests to find the best market segments and prospect lists;

·       Special offer tests to identify the incentives that encourage a prospect to join; and

·       Marketing channel tests to properly allocate budgets for direct mail, email, online advertising, and telemarketing.

The outcome of the testing resulted in an integrated channel, multi-touch recruitment program. The annual marketing efforts featured six recruitment campaigns each year. These campaigns include direct mail to former members and contacts in the ANA database, along with rented third-party lists and multiple emails. Results showed that when email efforts were sent simultaneously with direct mail, both channels saw improvement.

Additionally, ANA ran paid digital advertising continually throughout the year. The most effective ads drove prospects directly to the ANA join page and annually produced up to 5,000 new paid members. The digital program has advertised on Google, LinkedIn, and Facebook.

Digital ads on Facebook were particularly effective for ANA to recruit new members. [2] The online techniques included using Facebook custom audience ads that showed ads to an uploaded list of prospects who were also receiving direct mail and email membership offers. ANA also found success with Facebook lookalike ads that display invitations to candidates who look like current ANA members. Retargeting ads to prospects who visited the ANA website but had not made the decision to join produced outstanding results.

Another major step to enhance marketing effectiveness was to build a prospect database and score potential members on their likelihood to join based on their previous behavior, original source, and demographics. Those individuals with a high score received the full complement of marketing efforts. However, for those individuals who were much less likely to join, they only received lower-cost marketing efforts like an email or digital ad.

To continue to accelerate growth, ANA also launched a successful early career membership campaign to reach younger nurses. Like many other associations, ANA tends to have members in their 40’s and 50’s. ANA used content marketing to build an early career prospect list by offering a “new to the profession” welcome kit. Early career members also received a substantial discount on dues, a private online community, and had access to a mentor program. [3]

Through this strategy of focusing on value and then funding and executing a sophisticated recruitment program, ANA overcame its steep membership decline and established a sustainable program resulting in an increase in membership from 90,000 to more than 150,000. [4]

Because ANA had already established such a powerful membership marketing infrastructure when the COVID-19 pandemic hit along with the subsequent recession, the association was able to adapt the tools that it had created to meet the critical needs of members and the nursing community. For example, ANA developed a free COVID-19 webinar series and made it available at no charge to both members and nonmembers. They promoted the webinar series via email and paid digital advertising and drew over 130,000 registrations. By meeting the needs of nurses during this time, ANA also experienced a dramatic rise in new members. Membership grew by 12 percent in April and May of 2020, with over 23,000 new joins. [5]  This increase represented the highest new member recruitment levels in the history of the organization.

How can your organization develop a program to drive membership growth? The next section of this book presents each of the critical components for building your membership recruitment success story.

This article is an excerpt from the book Membership Recruitment: How to Grow Recurring Revenue, Reach New Markets, and Advance Your Mission. Find it on Amazon.



[1] Membership Acquisition: Follow the ROI.“ Associations Now

[2] “Member Acquisition.”

[3] “Is Career Stage the Key to Member Acquisition?”

[4] Carol Cohen and Elisa Joseph, “Membership CPR:  From Flagging to Thriving in Just 5 Years.”

[5] Lisa Boylan, “Membership Success Stories Amid COVID-19.”

Using Member-Get-A-Member Programs to Generate More Loyal and Valuable Members

As long as there have been membership organizations, there probably have been member-get-a-member (MGM) programs. It makes a lot of sense. Your members are likely to be in contact with others who share the same interests and needs as they do. 

Plus, as noted in an article in the Harvard Business Review, “Why Customer Referrals Can Drive Stunning Profits” a study of “10,000 accounts in a large German bank over a period of three years found that customers obtained through referrals are both more loyal and more valuable than other customers.”

Our 2015 Membership Marketing Benchmarking Report highlights that once again “word of mouth” referrals is reported as the most effective membership recruitment channel for associations.

So how can membership organizations harness the power of referrals? From my exploration of MGM programs, I have not seen a single “right” way to run these programs. A common theme of effectiveness for MGM programs, however, seems to be making the program simple and being consistent in the request and expectation of asking members for referrals.

Also most MGM programs include some type of incentive to encourage members to participate. These come in the form of gifts or financial incentives, some type of contest, or recognition before your peers in the association. You should note that there a many legal requirements that need to be fulfilled if you use any type of sweepstakes offer or drawing. Additionally, CAN-SPAM restrictions apply when a member provides a colleagues email address to you without the prospects opt-in.  I do not attempt to cover those issues here.

Here are three examples of member-get-a-member programs that I am familiar with from different associations.


The first is a “free trial” membership approach. Current members are sent tickets – like those pictured here -- that offer a six month, no-obligation membership in the organization. The strength of this program is that members do not need to sell anything. They are simply asked to give away a sample of something that they value and use themselves. Additionally, both the member and the trial member are entered into a drawing for participating in the program.


A second example is from an organization that I have been a member of for years – the IEEE. Each year, they send me a set of cards in my renewal notice and ask me to distribute them. The member writes their name and membership number on the card, so when the invitee signs up for membership online, the member information is can be entered and captured. Specific financial rewards are provided by IEEE for recruiting members. Here is a link to the MGM web site for IEEE that gives full details on how this program works.

Another example is the MGM program of a trade association. Their referral program focuses the giving the member the privileged of conferring a new member dues discount to the company that they refer. If you or someone from your member company recommends a firm for membership, then you have the opportunity to also give them a 20 percent discount for their first year dues payment.

Finally, here is another MGM site that I like where the association simply requests members to provide them with the name and address of prospective members and then the association does the follow up work.  This is a program that I used years ago as a mailed nomination process, but it became cost prohibitive.  But using a website to at least collected prospect names even though it requires a mail follow-up makes sense. 

Along with the advantages of MGM programs, I think one of the biggest mistakes made is the assumption that a member-get-a-member will be a silver bullet to solve membership recruitment challenges. How often have I heard the statement, “if every members recruits another member, we will double in size.”

MGM programs can be a part of the recruitment solution. However, no matter how hard you try or what you promise, only a small, highly motivated percentage of members will be comfortable with or interested in serving as an evangelist for you. So use MGM programs as part of your recruitment portfolio, but do not view it as a comprehensive solution.

Monthly Installment Dues Billing: A Case Study


Everyone wants to increase their membership recruitment results and renewal rates and here is one tip to do just that – monthly installment billing of dues.

If you think about it, our society has moved to a month by month financial focus. Your cell phone, internet, car payment, and service contracts are paid each month. In fact, our likelihood to purchase these products would be greatly diminished if we were required to pay for the year in advance. We are also more likely to continue the services when the payments are automatically debited from our credit card or bank account.

However, most membership organizations do not offer the opportunity to pay monthly. A member is typically required to pay the full dues up front.

Over the past several years, we experimented with making monthly installment billing available to members. I wanted to share with you today a case study from one organization that has tried this program.

Let me start out by admitting that putting this type of program in place is an administrative challenge. Credit cards expire and have transaction fees. In the case of electronic funds transfers (EFT), bank accounts open and close. So this type of change will require staff time and programming time. The higher the dues payment, the more beneficial this type of program will be.

For my case study group, the idea to test installment billing was first raised as a method to increase response rates on membership acquisition mailings. Research showed that the $225 price tag for dues was an impediment for members to join.

So we built a head to head acquisition test for this organization. The control offer with the $225 price went to 37,640 prospects and the same package offering the additional option of an automatic credit card payment of $18.75 a month went to 37,623 prospects. The results were impressive. The control package generated 436 new members for a 1.16% response rate. However, the test package with the installment option produced 657 members fro a 1.75% response rate.

Clearly many prospects were more willing to join if they had the option to pay monthly.

The next question was how will members who select the monthly installment renew compared to members who pay up front. Our latest data reports on members who renewed on time. The on time renewal rate for members NOT on the installment plan is 55.7%. However, the on time renewal rate for members participating in the installment plan is 82.0%. The non-installment member rate will probably rise to 70% when late renewal payments are included. But even when late payments are included, a potential twelve point lift in renewals is a major improvement.

The bottom line for this organization is that making an installment dues option available to members has caused an increase in the work load for staff, but it has helped produce more new members, more revenue and a better renewal rate. It may be something that more membership organizations should test.

Does the Washington Post have the Full Story?

The Washington Post headlined the struggles of associations today on the front page of the Business Section. The article presented a pretty dire story faced by many associations. The Post says,

“Reflecting the economic turmoil of the industries they represent, many national trade associations based in Washington are hemorrhaging members who either have lost their jobs, run a financially distressed business or said they need to spend their dwindling discretionary dollars on necessities rather than dues.” [1]

Clearly, associations serving industries in decline have a tougher road than others.

But it is also good to keep in mind that applying best membership marketing practices and meeting member needs during challenging times can and does still result in growth.

Here is one example spotlighted in a press release about the exceptional growth this year for the Society of Human Resource Management (SHRM). Membership has gone from 36,000 in 1992 to 250,000 this year making them one of the largest U.S. associations.

In part, SHRM attributes this rise in membership to the aggressive membership acquisition program that they launched in 1992 and have consistently maintained and improved over the years.

I think that Michael Treacy says in well, “Growth endures not because of fortuitous demand, a hot product, or any single tactic. Growth endures when management follows a portfolio of disciplines to ensure that a broad set of growth opportunities are identified and captured as routinely as costs are controlled and processes are improved.” [2]

Is your organization disciplined in it approach to growth?

[1] By V. Dion Haynes, Washington Post Staff Writer, Trade Groups Regroup, Monday, December 15, 2008; Page D01
[2] Michael Treacy, Double-Digit Growth.

Selling Memberships 1,000 Members at a Time

I wanted to share a story today that my friend Chris Bluhm, Chief Operating Officer, of The American Occupational Therapy Association (AOTA) gave me permission to share with you.

Over the past several years, Chris and his colleagues have established the AOTA National Partnership Program. As part of the benefits, the program includes a block of memberships that the partner company provides to their staff. This results in instant company paid memberships for AOTA. However, the partners also greatly benefit from the program as tool to help them identify, recruit, and retain top occupational therapists.

Two companies, Genesis Rehab Services and RehabCare have joined the program so far. The most recent partnership will allow RehabCare’s almost 1,300 occupational therapy practitioners to have access to the educational and professional resources that AOTA offers to other members. The 1,300 members also represent a sizeable new member input for AOTA.

There are a couple of reasons why I wanted to share this story. First, because it is an example of very smart membership marketing and that is what this blog is all about. There are multiple ways to grow membership for an organization and it is wise to take advantage of each opportunity. Obviously, this all assumes that a sound financial rational has been put in place before initiating any agreements.

My second reason is that there can be a fear among non-profits of partnering with for profit companies. Just yesterday, I saw members of an association list serv cautioning against allowing for profits to buy membership and give them to customers because it might lower the perceived value of the association or result in higher non-renewals.

Here are some reasons why I like the idea of developing innovative forms of bulk membership offers like the National Partnership Program.

  1. Typically, the more paid members an organization has the better off it is financially. Fixed costs rarely grow at the same rate as membership volume. So each additional member provides additional margin or profits for the association. This is a big help in challenging economic times.
  2. Members – from any source -- should be the best customers an association has for professional development, certification, books, conference, etc. It is said, “A rising tide raises all boats. “
  3. To acquire members through most channels – direct mail, ads, exhibiting, and emails – costs money. But a program of bulk or membership sales will typically cost some time, but represent the least expensive new members that an organization adds.
  4. Many people who the partner or company may recruit for membership are the company’s employees or customer list. There may be no other way to access these people except through a bulk membership.
  5. The partner may renew the membership resulting in a higher renewal rate than would normally be achieved from first year members.
  6. The partner’s sponsoring of membership results in a very powerful third party endorsement of the organization in the mind of the new member.
  7. Members who may never have had the financial resources to join the organization on their own will be brought into your community.

Let me know if you agree or disagree with me on these points. Have you had any bulk membership or partnership experiences with membership? Please share them.

Case Study: Does this Marketing Stuff Really Work?

Can negative membership trends really be turned around through putting membership marketing best practices in place? Can marketing really make a difference even if the value proposition, dues pricing, and product offerings don’t change?

The answer is YES!

Clearly, any non-profit should offer the best value, optimum price and top product that it can. But just fixing the marketing component can have a big influence.

That’s why I appreciated the presentation done by Lori Jordan, Director of Association Services, for the Water Environment Federation (WEF) at the ASAE and the Center’s recent Marketing and Membership Conference.

According to her presentation, WEF had seen membership consistently decline beginning from 2001 to 2006. However, over the past three years through the deployment of an aggressive membership acquisition program and development of a multi-channel, high frequency renewal system, WEF membership began to climb.

In addition to adding new members through acquisition efforts, the new renewal system has helped the retention rate increase by an impressive 7 points.



The WEF story is an encouragement that there is hope for organizations that are experiencing a membership decline. If you would like a copy of the full presentation, please send me an email. My address is on the sidebar of the blog or you can reach me through LinkedIn.

In full disclosure, please note that WEF has been a client of my firm, Marketing General, Inc., for the past three years.

What successful turn around stories have you seen? Please feel free to share your comments.

Managing Global Membership – One Organization’s Philosophy

ASAE and the Center’s Marketing and Membership Conference had some very useful sessions.

I found comments from Dan Rex, Deputy Executive Director and Director of Communications and Marketing for Toastmasters International to be particularly of interest.

He spoke about his organizations global growth and the philosophy that they have followed. Toastmasters “now have nearly 226,000 members in 11,500 clubs in 92 countries.”

It appears to me from the presentation that Toastmasters is following a pretty tightly controlled global strategy. For example, Toastmasters has resisted the temptation to establish offices outside of the US. All staff is based out of their California office.

Additionally, they have made the decision to provide limited customer service hours from 8:00 am to 5:00 pm Pacific Time and customer service is only in English. Their policy states that “Toastmasters International does not have the World Headquarters staff resources or financial sources at this time to provide oral or written translation services. Communications sent to or sent by World Headquarters will be in English. It is understood, however, that change to policy will be considered in the future as the translation environment changes.”

Toastmasters has done only limited translation of their extensive materials driven by specific numbers of clubs in a language group. I saw Spanish, French, and Chinese transitions on their web site. Wisely, Toastmasters also tightly their trademark and copyrights with a clearly outlined policy and pro-active enforcement.

They do, however, give volunteers and prospective clubs many downloadable tools and resources to help them get started. In essence they have made membership self service through the web. And volunteers from around the world have been the key to launching new clubs and producing their growth and success.

By the way, here is a link to their 10 Tips for public speaking.

What do you think of the global membership philosophy employed by this group?

Five Phases of the Membership Life Cycle


We have just put out a new white paper titled the Membership Marketing Life Cycle. It highlights the five major phases in the membership lifecycle:
  • Awareness
  • Recruitment
  • Engagement
  • Interdependence
  • Renewal
Over the next few posts, I would like to highlight each of these phases in the membership lifecycle.

First, let’s take a look at awareness. Membership marketing starts with one very important question. Do prospective members know who you are?Awareness is the measure of how successful your branding efforts have been to gain share of mind in your target audience. Until someone knows you, they are not likely to become a member or a customer. Or put another way, how does the bee find the flower?
Good direct marketing alone is not the best or most effective tool to build awareness. For example, the United Professional Sales Association (UPSA), desired to expand its strong and thriving local organization beyond the Washington, DC area. Members of UPSA attended meetings and established meaningful networking relationships.
However, when UPSA conducted a national membership development campaign, the results were less than they hoped to receive. The promotion was targeted to an audience that tracked with local membership. The challenge appeared to be one of awareness. The market that they sought to reach did not know and recognize their brand.

Fortunately, there are some tools available to membership marketers to help build awareness. These include:
  • Search engine optimization
  • Search engine ads
  • Public Relations
  • Word of Mouth Marketing
And when awareness is raised in key constituencies, results will follow. The U.S. Naval Institute (USNI) provides a good example this. USNI just completed a very strong membership growth year, but this growth was supported by a series of videos titled, Americans at War that highlighted the real life stories of their members. These video testimonies were so powerful that they went from You Tube to being picked up on run on PBS stations across the country.

How do you know if awareness is the challenge facing your membership marketing? The best way to find out may be to conduct a small test marketing effort to the prospects that you feel would be interested in joining your organization. If the returns are acceptable, there is enough awareness to move forward. If not, it might be time to cultivate a higher level of awareness before investing funds in selling.

Frequency of Contact in Membership Marketing


In my earlier post this week on Sensible Branding, I emphasized the importance of frequently communicating your brand to your target audience.

I thought that it might be helpful to follow that up with some actual test results.

Earlier this year, we conducted an A/B split membership acquisition test for an organization where we added a follow up email promotion two weeks after our mailing dropped to a portion of the file. The email carried the same graphics and special offer that was included in the mailing.

Here is what we found. The prospects who receive only the mailed membership invitation responded at a .57% response rate. Those who received both the mailing and the follow up email generated a total response rate of .97%.

Adding the email cost very little, but raised overall response rates by 68%. That’s adding 3.9 members for each thousand contacts. Let’s say the dues rate is $200, then the additional email generated $780 more dues revenue for each thousand people contacted. Not bad.

Within reason, good membership marketing requires frequent contact with prospects, ideally using multiple channels.

The AARP Growth Strategy

Yesterday’s post, My Favorite Growth Strategy – Market Expansion, outlined the theory of growing membership through market expansion. I thought that it might be interesting to take a look at the classic example of using this strategy today – AARP

In 1947, Dr. Ethel Percy Andrus, a retired high school principal, founded the National Retired Teachers Association (NRTA). But after ten years of operation, in 1958, NRTA evolved into AARP when Andrus opened the organization to all senior Americans.

“Apart from a bumpy period in the late '70s, AARP's rolls have risen rapidly each year since its founding in 1958: 1958 50,000 1968 1.6 million 1978 11.8 million 1988 30 million“(Money Magazine).

Membership was boosted in 1984 when AARP further expanded its markets by lowering the age of membership eligibility from 55 to 50.

Today AARP reports 38 million members.

Clearly, the AARP growth included favorable demographics, market need for insurance and other products, and a good membership value proposition. However, if AARP did not look beyond its original narrow teacher market, some other organization would be serving seniors today instead.

That’s why market expansion is so important.

Thinking broadly about who might benefit from the products and services provided by an association can lead to substantial growth.

Know the Numbers on Membership Marketing

'Know the numbers' is the best advice that anyone can give you when it comes to membership marketing. Knowing the numbers can help answer key marketing questions like: 'What is the value of a member?', 'How much can I afford to spend to obtain a member?', and 'What is my membership retention rate?

The following formulas are provided as a handy reference tool for membership marketers to help them take a strategic look at the economics of membership.

Renewal Rate
  • Renewal Rate measures the number of members kept over a given period of time -- usually during a fiscal or calendar year.
    · Total Number of Members Today (minus 12 months of new members) / Total Number of Members in Previous Year
    · Example: (105 - 15)/100 = 90% Renewal Rate
Average Tenure
  • How long on average do members stay with an association?
    · Reciprocal of Renewal Rate: 1 – Renewal Rate or, 1 - .90 = .10
    · Example: Divide Reciprocal into 1, or, 1 /.10 = an Average Tenure of 10 years

Lifetime Value (LTV)

  • Assume $100 / Year Dues and $50 / Year in Non-Dues Revenue
    · (Dues + Non-Dues Revenue) x Average Tenure = LTV
    · Example: ($100 + $50) x 10 = $1,500 LTV

Maximum Acquisition Cost (MAC)

  • Assume Incremental Servicing Costs = $20 and Cost of Goods Sold = $25
    · ((Dues + Non-Dues Revenue) - (Incremental Servicing Costs + Costs of Goods Sold)) x Avg. Tenure = MAC
    · Example: (($100 + $50) - ($20 + $25)) x 10 = $1,050 MAC