Podcast: Pandemics Impact on Associations
New Report Highlights Impact of Pandemic on Associations
In the just-released Association Economic Outlook Report, over 500 association executives shared how the pandemic and the recession have impacted their organizations.
They reported substantial disruptions.
· 78% canceled or postponed their in-person
events this year
· 39% see their membership as going down by the
end of the year
· 20% cut the salaries or hours of their
employees
· 18% reported layoffs with no intention to
bring back those staff members
Nevertheless, associations have responded
forcefully to address these circumstances.
Most notably, the present challenges have decreased the impediments to change and innovation experienced by associations. A year ago, in the 2019 Economic Outlook Report, respondents said that some of the barriers to change were institutional resistance to risk and the slow pace of board and senior executive decision making. As this chart highlights this year’s data shows that some of those impediments have substantially declined.
In response to the current challenges, associations are making adjustments.
· 84% have increased their virtual professional
development opportunities
· 78% have developed new products and services
to assist members and member companies
· 77% of those that canceled their in-person
events replaced it with a virtual event
· 72% have reevaluated and streamline internal
processes
As associations deliver essential
services to members, they see the impact. Fully 69% say that member engagement has
increased during this year. For those willing to provide critical information,
networking, and community to members during hard times, the results can be increased
loyalty and organizational resilience. The message is, do not waste the
opportunity for innovation and change that challenging times bring.
You can download the full EconomicOutlook Report here.
Helpful Membership Marketing Links
Over the past year, my firm has issued a number of reports and guides that provide some trustworthy insights on how to manage and develop a successful membership marketing program. Here is a consolidation of links to those resources.
1.
The Fall 2020 edition of the Association Economic Outlook
Report
2.
The Membership
Renewal Guide
3.
2020 editions of MGI’s 15 Minutes to
Impact Membership Podcasts
4.
The Guide to
Membership Marketing Metrics
5.
Tipster
Newsletter Archive
6.
The 12th Edition of the Membership Marketing
Benchmarking Report
Association Preparedness for Potential Economic Challenges
These are some of the questions that we asked in our just-published Association Economic Outlook Report. The report provides insights from nearly 400 association executives who participated in the research.
You may find the research to be relevant to your organization based on the current economic news. You can get your copy of the report using this link.
How Understanding Lifetime Value Powers Your Membership Marketing
Should Associations Pursue a Membership or Customer Strategy?
- Based on our 2018 Membership Marketing Benchmarking Report, the mean renewal rate for an association member is 81%. This translates to an average tenure (how long a member continues membership) of 5 years. So membership provides an ongoing income stream of revenue and only 19% of members need to be replaced each year to maintain counts.
- In data analytics completed for one client, we found the renewal rate of a customer (someone who attended a meeting, bought a book, or went to a conference more than one time) was 8%. So the customer tenure was 1.2 years. To maintain customer levels, essentially 92% of customers needed to be replaced each year.
- In this same analysis, the median lifetime value for a member was $516 while the median lifetime value for a customer was $100.
- Finally, the cost to acquire a new member or customer is one of the more expensive marketing efforts. While the cost to renew an existing member or customer is usually a fraction of the marketing cost. But as noted, a membership continues for a number of years through renewal efforts and while the pipeline of customers’ requires more extensive acquisition efforts to stay full.
Every association is different, so to determine the optimum strategy some analysis of purchasing patterns and lifetime value is required. But when exploring a strategy, an important component to include in the calculation is not just first year of sales, but to calculate the lifetime value of a member and a customer.
Calculating the Cost to Serve a Member
Here is a real life story on how NOT to calculate the cost to serve a member. One of my clients presented the following analysis to his staff. He took the entire budget for his organization and divided it by the number of members and determined that the cost to service a member who annually paid $79 in dues was $300 ($3,000,000/10,000 members).
Shocked and with tongue in cheek, I told him that the best solution for the organization was to email all of the members and tell them not to renew – they would save $221 for each member who did not return. Of course they would have to survive without the $800,000 in dues revenue and some portion of the non-dues, advertising, and exhibitor revenue dependent on members.
But in all seriousness, when an organization assigns too much cost to serving a member, the calculation can kill a membership program. Why would an organization spend even the smallest amount of money on recruiting or renewing a member when the cost to serve approached the annual dues rate?
So what is the best way to determine the cost to serve a member? I believe that the optimal method is to base the analysis on incremental servicing cost.
The incremental cost is simply made up of the variable costs that the association would incur to serve an estimated number of additional members. These variable costs might be as simple as printing and mailing additional magazines and renewal notices. You can determine these incremental costs by working with suppliers to get an estimate of what the additional cost would be if, for example, you printed and mailed and additional 1,000 magazines and sent out additional renewal notices to 1,000 more members and then divided these costs by that number of members. A typical association might find these costs are less than $20 per member and not the $300 per member noted earlier.
Clearly over time for a rapidly growing association the incremental cost method poses some problems. At some point, additional staff will be required to serve members and office space might need to be expanded. But I have witnessed clients growing membership by 50 percent and not adding staff or additional space.
The other approach to calculating servicing costs is to try to define the “real” costs to serve a member. The challenge is that what those real costs are is highly subjective. Should the servicing costs include some portion of the CEO’s salary? What about the editorial staff that works on publishing the magazine for members? Should only the office space occupied by the membership department be assigned to the cost or the space used by others? Are marketing communications sent to members a cost and if so does the membership revenue budget get credited with the non-dues purchases made by members? How does the cost of insurance, software, and staff travel get assigned?
All these costs in theory can be assessed and monitored over time. However, does this really provide a clearer picture or simply reflect someone’s arbitrary judgment call?
The bottom line is that for most associations, serving members is the reason that the organization exists. And in addition to dues revenue, most product purchases, registrations, exhibit and advertising revenue are driven by the existence of members. So understanding that there are costs to provide services to members needs to factor into any economic calculation, but following a simple incremental cost calculation will provide the fundamental information needed at a considerable savings of time and debate.
Tips for Forecasting Membership Growth in the New Year
Four Questions to Answer before Setting a Membership Growth Goal
How to Budget for Membership Recruitment and Renewals
Most membership marketing budgets are built backwards. An organization determines how much it can spend and then asks the membership staff to use it in the best way possible.
But the correct question should not be how much you are allowed to spend, but how much you can generate in revenue for the organization. In other words, base budgets on the harvest, not on the cost of the seeds.
Here is an example.
One group that I work with on renewals has an average dues rate of $95. They run a nine part mail renewal program with supporting emails. The incremental cost to service a member is approximately $24 per member.
Here is how much they spend to renew each member from each renewal effort (cost of the renewal effort divided by the number of members renewing with that effort):
• Effort #1 -- $ 2.31
• Effort #2 -- $ 4.05
• Effort #3 -- $ 8.75
• Effort #4 -- $10.24
• Effort #5 -- $15.96
• Effort #6 -- $10.15
• Effort #7 -- $ 9.36
• Effort #8 -- $ 20.54
• Effort #9 -- $ 37.61
So by the last effort, they are spending over $37 to get a member to renew. Is that too much? I would argue that it is probably makes good economic sense for this organization to push even harder for renewals because they are still making a profit for the organization on effort #9 of $33.84 per member (($37.61 + $24.00) – ($95) = $33.84).
The good news is that this group is basing a renew budget on return on investment that they monitor for each effort instead of on an arbitrary cost budget.
The same evaluation can be done for membership recruitment. As I noted in my August 16th post, a new member will produce a predictable income stream for an organization. This income stream is called lifetime value.
If you know the lifetime value of a member and the cost to service the member each year, you can establish the “margin” that a new member will produce for the organization over time. Knowing the lifetime margin a new member will produce then allows you to build a budget based on ROI instead of on what funds are allocated or might be available for membership recruitment.
So with the organization highlighted above, if the average member stays for 5 years, the dues revenue stream is $475 and the five year servicing cost is $120, producing a lifetime margin of $355.
Knowing these numbers allows the recruitment budgeting discussion to be driven by how much the organization wants to invest to produce $355 income stream from each new member.
The bottom line is that you should not budget backwards for membership marketing. Budget based on the return on investment that each membership marketing dollar will produce for your organization.
3 Tips on How to Improve the Presentation of Your Membership Product
How membership is presented is also important when promoting to prospective members.
So when I came across some behavioral concepts from the consumer market in the Mckinsey Quarterly magazine, I thought that they could be applied to how we market and present our membership product. Here they are.
1. Offering payment terms – Many organizations find that adding a bill-me to a membership promotion or offering installment billing can improve responses. In fact, over 45% of associations report that they now offer a dues installment payment option. Similarly “retailers know that allowing consumers to delay payment can dramatically increase their willingness to buy. One reason delayed payments work is perfectly logical: the time value of money makes future payments less costly than immediate ones. But there is a second, less rational basis for this phenomenon. Payments, like all losses, are viscerally unpleasant. But emotions experienced in the present—now—are especially important. Even small delays in payment can soften the immediate sting of parting with your money and remove an important barrier to purchase.”1.
2. Offering a tiered membership with lower and higher priced options – I have commented in the past on the benefits of developing a tiered (or multi-level) membership product. These tiers allow a member to pick the best value for themselves and allow the organization to maximize its share of wallet. As an example from the retail world, “many restaurants find that the second-most-expensive bottle of wine is very popular—and so is the second-cheapest. Customers who buy the former feel they are getting something special but not going over the top. Those who buy the latter feel they are getting a bargain but not being cheap.” 2.
3. Bundling diverse additional services into a membership package – The opposite problem of having only one membership category is having a membership with lots of choices like interest sections, local chapters, and optional periodicals. This complexity can actually reduce response rates. In fact, “reducing the number of options makes people likelier not only to reach a decision but also to feel more satisfied with their choice.”3.
Trying new ways to present membership really comes down to making the buying decision easier for a prospective member. We make it easier for them to buy if we offer payment over time and if we give a member a product that both meets a member's diverse needs, but also is not too complex or cumbersome to purchase.
What other suggestions do you have to better present membership in your organization?
1. Ned Welch, A marketer’s guide to behavioral economics, McKinsey Quarterly, February 2010.
2. Ibid.
3. Ibid.
3 Membership Marketing New Year’s Resolutions
1. Adequately Fund Membership Marketing – Just like putting money into retirement savings, investing in membership pays dividends for years to come. A new member produces a long term income stream. However, as I meet with membership organizations, I am continually surprised at the budgets that have been set aside for marketing. Almost every organization wants to grow their membership, but rarely do I see budgets that are tied to the lifetime value of a potential member. Lack of funding means many organizations are leaving money on the table and missing their potential by not crunching the numbers to determine how much they should be investing in getting more members.
2. Initiate and Cultivate Potential Member Relationships – We find that a promotion sent to a prospective member who provided an opt-in to receive more information from an organization will garner up to four times the response than the next best list. To gather this opt-in, we offer free content from our clients in exchange for contact information (an opt-in). The content offer may be presented through SEM, online ads, or to visitors to the organizations website or social media sites. The key is to initiate the lead and then cultivate the relationship.
3. Test and Track Membership Marketing Efforts – If you want to double or triple your marketing returns over the next year, then setting up marketing tests with a control and test cell is your best opportunity. You can test what marketing list is most responsive, what message is most compelling, and what offer best encourages action. To test you need to code the outbound marketing pieces and track the responses as they are returned. To capture un-coded responses, match back returns to your promotion file.
These membership marketing resolutions are summed up well by a comment from one of my survey respondent who wrote:
“When you actually do a recruitment campaign, they join. When you engage with your members, they stay. When you analyze the data, you find a nugget of information that can change all of your preconceived ideas.”
What are your membership marketing resolutions for 2011?
How Long does the Average Member Stay with an Association?
Here is how you can calculate this for your membership. Take the lapse rate of the membership (the opposite of the renewal rate) in a decimal form and divide it into the number 1. So a membership organization with an 80% renewal rate would have a lapse rate of 20% and an average tenure of five years (1/.20= 5).
Another way of looking at this calculation is if you have a 20% lapse rate, your membership will turn over every five years.
So what would be the “average”, Average Tenure for membership organizations?
In our 2010 Membership Marketing Benchmarking Report with over 400 participating associations, our average renewal rate was 83%. So this would put the Average Tenure of a member at 5.88 years for the participating organizations.
Please be aware that this is an average for the participating organizations. Some reported renewal rates less than 50% and others more than 90%.
Knowing the Average Tenure of your membership is a crucial data point to use in marketing planning and making long term budget projections.
Calculating Membership Lifetime Value

Understanding lifetime value (LTV) is a fundamental calculation that every membership organization should do. It let’s you know how much you can spend to acquire and keep your members. It is the foundation for a membership marketing strategy.
There are some shortcuts that I use these days to get to the numbers a little more quickly, but the article is worth reviewing.
The article was written by Harmon O. Pritchard, Jr., who at the time was senior vice president of membership for the Aircraft Owners and Pilots Association (AOPA). Harmon along with Scott McBride, the founder of Marketing General, Inc. were really the first to apply the LTV concept to membership marketing world.
Here is the link:
http://tinyurl.com/ltvarticle
Let me know what you think.
What Research Says about Marketing during a Recession?
The article looks says “numerous studies have shown that companies that keep spending on acquisition, advertising, and R. & D. during recessions do significantly better than those which make big cuts.”[1]
The article is worth reading and could be useful in arguing against the budget cuts that are being imposed on so many of you who I talk to about this. Let me know what you think.
[1] James Surowiecki, Hanging Tough, The New Yorker, by April 20, 2009
Important Membership Marketing Formulas
Renewal Rate
- Renewal Rate measures the number of members kept over a given period of time -- usually during a fiscal or calendar year.
- Total Number of Members Today (minus 12 months of new members) / Total Number of Members in Previous Year
- Example: (10,500 - 1,500)/10,000 = 90% Renewal Rate
- Average Tenure measures how long on average a member stays with an association.
- Reciprocal of Renewal Rate: 1 – Renewal Rate or, 1 - .90 = .10
- Example: Divide Reciprocal into 1, or, 1 /.10 = an Average Tenure of 10 years
- Life Time Value measures the revenue stream that a member will produce.
- Assume $100 / Year Dues and $50 / Year in Non-Dues Revenue
Dues + Non-Dues Revenue) x Average Tenure = LTV - Example: ($100 + $50) x 10 = $1,500 LTV
- Maximum Acquisition Cost measures the long term net incremental value (or margin) of a member.
- Assume Incremental Servicing Costs = $20 and Cost of Goods Sold = $25
- (Dues + Non-Dues Revenue) - (Incremental Servicing Costs + Costs of Goods Sold) x Avg. Tenure = MAC
- Example: (($100 + $50) - ($20 + $25)) x 10 = $1,050 MAC
- Steady State projects the long term equilibrium of a membership based on current new member input and lapse rates.
- Annual New Member Input / Reciprocal of Renewal Rate (or Lapse Rate) Shown as a Decimal = Total Membership Steady State.
- Example: 20,000 New Member Input / .25 Lapse Rate = 80,000 Total Membership.
Five Reasons We will Avoid Depression II
You can click on the picture to get a larger view.












